If you’re hunting for a pizza spot that nails both classic and inventive flavors, New York Pizza Company on Frankfort Avenue in Louisville is a solid pick. Their menu is stacked with options that cater to every kind of pizza lover. The specialty pies are a standout, from the Grandma Meatball Pie in both medium 14" and XL 20" sizes to the delicate Margherita or the indulgent Hot Honey Pepperoni XL. Each comes on New York-style thin crust that’s crisp yet chewy, making each bite satisfying without being overwhelming. For those who like experimenting, the “Create Your Own Pizza” options let you build from medium 14" to XL 20", including a gluten-free artisan crust, ensuring everyone can get exactly what they crave.
Sides and appetizers are perfect for sharing or adding a little extra punch. The new imported pepperoncinis and fresh banana peppers bring some sharp freshness, while classics like fried mozzarella sticks, buffalo chicken fritters with ranch, and a side of buffalo or ranch dressing round out the menu. Specialty pizzas like Sausage-Mushrooms-Onions or the XL Jamaican Jerk Chicken keep things exciting, and the Virtual Slice Counter makes grabbing a massive 1/4 slice of your favorite pie super convenient. Even the desserts are worth mentioning-creamy New York cheesecake, tiramisu, or the buy-one-get-one double chocolate chip muffins are a sweet finish to a hearty meal.
Drinks and beer options add to the casual, fun vibe. From bottled Sprites and Cherry Coke to a small beer garden featuring Yuengling, Modelo Especial, and Coors varieties, you can pair your slice perfectly. Overall, New York Pizza Company offers a versatile menu that balances authenticity and creativity, making it an easy go-to for a quick slice, a shareable feast, or a full dinner experience.